All-in-one touchscreen displays with Android.

Knowledge and advice

Comparing narrowcasting software: criteria and practical test

Use the same test for every supplier. Compare content, device support, planning, rights, management and the full costs.

First draw up a short requirements brief

A good comparison starts with what your organisation will actually do. List the number of screens and locations, the operating systems, the users and the types of content. Then describe a few daily tasks: replacing a video, publishing a message for one location and removing an expired promotion. Distinguish between necessary functions and wishes for later. That way you do not compare a cheap basic package with an extensive solution of which you only need a small part.

Criterion 1: devices and files

Have the supplier demonstrate that the player works on your exact display. An all-in-one Android model has a built-in computer and can play suitable content independently; external player hardware is not necessarily needed. Check screen orientation, resolution, supported file types, auto-start and behaviour after a power outage. Use real files with the format and length of your daily material. A demo video that works on another device is insufficient proof for your setup.

Criterion 2: publishing and planning

Ask how a design change becomes a visible screen. Is there a preview and can you undo an incorrect publication? If timing is required, test a start and end time, time zone and the transition to regular content. With multiple locations, it must be clear how shared and local content are assigned. The additional Pixio App offers a route for remote management; have the desired details confirmed separately rather than assuming all CMS functions by default.

Criterion 3: accounts, data and continuity

Determine which employees may design, review and publish. Show whether users only see the screens for which they are responsible. Check the processing and retention period of any personal data. Then test what a screen does when the internet goes down and what message the administrator receives. A subscription or open-source licence does not guarantee complete security or uninterrupted operation. Record who performs updates, backups and recovery and what agreed support actually includes.

Criterion 4: integrations and real costs

Describe external data sources separately. A calendar, product stock or checkout system requires supported software and permission for access. Let the link work with a limited test set before you approve it. Then compare subscription, player licences, installation, storage, users, integrations and support over the same period. The open-source Xibo CMS and the commercial Xibo Android player illustrate why a CMS price alone is not enough. Conditions for a free account can also change once you add more screens.

Make the practical test decisive

Use the same tasks for every candidate: log in, edit content, publish, check, restart and handle a network interruption. Note for each task whether it was successful, unsuccessful or additional setup is needed, with the implications for costs and management. Have the employee who will use the system in future take part. Ask the supplier to include the outcome and missing components in the proposal. The best choice is the solution that demonstrably performs the agreed tasks and that your organisation can maintain.

Sources and further information

Frequently asked questions

Which practical test gives a fair comparison?

Have every candidate upload, publish, check, restart and handle a network interruption with the same content.

Does a demo prove all required integrations?

No. Let the specific source, permissions and error handling work in a limited real test.

Read also

The full price list

Request the price list brochure

The brochure brings all displays together, with the available purchase, rental and lease prices, versions and options. You will receive the price list by email.

Prefer a different step right away?

We use your data to provide the price list and follow up on your enquiry. You do not need to sign up for updates for this.

We will process your request and follow up by email. A Pixio specialist responds within one working day.